HiPP Organic Baby Formula vs Holle Organic Baby Formula

Since many parents get confused with the choice of organic baby formulas available on the market, TheBestFromJapan.com has made a quick overview of two leading European brands.

Production

Both brands have over 60 years of organic farming history and comply with strict EU-Eco regulations. However, Holle, established in Switzerland, is a Demeter-certified baby formula manufacturer, while Germany-based HiPP labels products with its own Organic Seal of Quality.

List of Holle Products

  • Stage PRE (from birth)
  • Stage 1 (from birth)
  • Stage 2 (from 6 months)
  • Stage 3 (from 10 months)
  • Stage 4 (from 12 months)
  • Goat milk Stage 1 (from birth)
  • Goat milk Stage 2 (from 6 months)
  • Goat milk Stage 3 (from 10 months)

List of HIPP Products

  • Stage PRE (from birth)
  • Stage 1 (from birth)
  • Stage 2 (from 6 months)
  • Stage 3 (from 10 or 12 months)
  • Stage 4 (from 2 years)
  • Comfort milk (from birth)
  • Anti-reflux milk (from birth)
  • Hungry infant milk (from birth)
  • Good night milk (from 6 months)
  • Hypoallergenic Stage 1 (from birth)
  • Hypoallergenic Stage 2 (from 6 months)

Product Range

While Holle products are available in versions based on both goat and cow’s milk, HiPP boasts a wider range of formulas customized for babies’ specific needs. Actually, HiPP Stage 1 addresses allergic issues through its hypoallergenic line, containing pre-hydrolyzed milk protein, and offers an easier to digest formula in its Comfort Milk for infants suffering from colic and constipation. HiPP Hungry Infant Milk has a higher content of caseins to fill demanding babies, and its Anti-reflux milk features a natural thickener to prevent reflux and regurgitation.

Organic Formula Ingredients

HiPP organic baby formula stands out for prebiotics and probiotics included into most of its products, as well as for lactose content. Holle cow milk-based products (except for Stage Pre) are sweetened with maltodextrin, but both cow and goat’s milk lines are absolutely soy-free (the same can’t be said for some of HiPP’s milks). Starch, which is not recommended for babies under 6 months, is not contained in Holle PRE and 1 formula, yet it is found in HiPP Comfort Milk, Hypoallergenic and Germany Stage 1. Palm oil is used by both brands, but only HiPP adds LCP oils to all its products.

Hipp vs Holle – Bottom line

Though both manufacturers promote the best organic standards for infants and babies, we’d vote in favor of HiPP for its more balanced formulas and customized range of products.

Add Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.